The heading and title tag mistakes holding your website back

Not sure if your website's headings are set up right? Here's what to check in five minutes, and what to ask your web designer.
h1 tags web design

Article summary

  • Your title tag is the headline in Google and on the browser tab. Your H1 is the main heading on the page itself.
  • One clear H1 per page is best practice, even though Google can cope with more.
  • Choose heading levels for structure, not size.
  • You can check all of this in five minutes with a free Chrome extension, no code needed.

Your SEO plugin has flagged “missing H1”. Or you’ve searched for your own business and Google is showing a page title you never wrote. Either way, something’s telling you your headings are wrong, and you want to know how much that actually matters.

Here’s the honest answer: heading tag mistakes rarely sink a website on their own, but they make your pages harder for Google, AI search tools and your visitors to understand. Most are quick fixes, not rebuilds. And in the spirit of full transparency, the last version of this very post had no H2s at all. Every section was an H3 or H4. We’ve fixed it, and we’ll show you how to check yours.

Do headings and title tags actually matter for SEO?

Yes, but not as much as most SEO checklists suggest. Headings help Google understand what each section of a page covers, and your title tag is the main source for the clickable headline in search results. Neither is a magic ranking switch. Get them wrong, though, and your page is harder to read for people and search engines alike.

Headings (you’ll also hear them called header tags or H tags) run from H1 down to H6. Google’s John Mueller has said a page can rank perfectly well with no H1 or with several. What Google does say clearly, in its own Search Central documentation, is that it uses your title tag, your main heading and other prominent text on the page to decide what headline to show in results.

So a messy structure won’t get you “penalised”. It just means you have less say over how your page looks in Google, and that affects whether anyone clicks (which is where enquiries start).

There’s a human side too. People using screen readers jump from heading to heading to find their way around a page, much like you’d skim the subheadings in a newspaper. Muddled headings make that much harder.

Title tag vs H1: what’s the difference?

Your title tag is the headline shown in Google’s results and on the browser tab. Your H1 is the main heading visitors see on the page itself. They describe the same thing, so they should agree, but they don’t have to match word for word. The title earns the click; the H1 confirms the visitor is in the right place.

Title tagH1
Where it appearsGoogle results, browser tab, social sharesOn the page, usually at the top
Who reads itSearchers deciding whether to clickVisitors already on your page
How many per pageOneOne is best practice
Where you edit it (WordPress)Your SEO pluginYour page editor

On WordPress, you’ll set the title tag in Rank Math or Yoast, and the H1 in the page editor itself.

How to check your own website in five minutes

You don’t need to read any code. Install a free Chrome extension such as SEO Meta in 1 Click, open the page you want to check and click the icon. It shows your title tag, meta description and every heading in order, so you can spot a missing H1 or a jumbled structure in seconds.

seo one click meta title

Check your title tag

  1. Open the extension and look at the title line.
  2. Ask yourself: is it specific to this page, and does it say what you do (and where, if you’re local)?
  3. If it just says “Home”, your business name, or the same thing as three other pages, add it to your fix list.

Check your headings

  1. Open the Headers tab in the extension.
  2. You’re looking for one H1 near the top that names the page’s topic, then H2s for the main sections, with H3s sitting under them.
  3. Make a note of anything odd: several H1s, your logo listed as a heading, or a heading that’s just “Call us today”.
seo one click meta extensions headings

Check what Google actually shows

Search Google for the page (or type site:yourdomain.co.uk to see them all). If the headline in the results is different from your title tag, Google has rewritten it. We’ll cover why that happens further down.

The most common heading tag mistakes (and how serious each one is)

The most common heading tag mistakes are choosing headings for their size rather than their role, having no H1 or several, skipping levels, and writing vague or duplicate title tags. Most take minutes to fix in your page editor or SEO plugin. Here’s how serious each one really is, so you know where to start.

MistakeHow seriousUsually fixed in
Headings chosen for size, not structureFix nowPage editor
No H1, or an H1 that says “Welcome”Fix nowPage editor
Vague, duplicate or name-only title tagsFix nowSEO plugin
Keyword stuffingFix nowSEO plugin and page editor
Several H1s on every pageFix when convenientTheme or header template
Skipped levels and decorative headingsTidy up when you next editPage editor

Headings chosen for size, not structure

This is the root of most heading problems we see. Page builders like Elementor let you pick any heading level for any bit of text, so it’s tempting to choose an H2 because it looks the right size, not because it starts a main section.

The result is testimonials, footer text and “Get in touch” buttons all marked up as headings. The fix is simple: set the level by its role on the page, then change the size in the styling settings.

No H1, or an H1 that says “Welcome”

Your H1 should tell people (and Google) exactly what the page is about. “Welcome to our website” doesn’t. Neither does your logo, which some themes set as the H1 on every page.

A good H1 for a service page sounds like what a customer would search for: “Fitted kitchens on the Isle of Wight” beats “Our services” every time.

Several H1s on every page

Google has said its systems can handle more than one H1, so this one won’t tank your rankings. It does blur the message about what the page is really about, for visitors, for screen readers and for Google picking your headline.

We recently audited a property client’s website where every single page carried at least three H1s. This was an issue caused where ‘H1’ seemed to deliver a different sized text that seemed suitable for the page. Partly down to the website design, partly down to a misunderstanding of SEO heading tags.

When it happens on every page like this, it’s usually coming from the theme or header template, so one fix can often clear the whole site.

Skipped levels and headings used as decoration

Jumping from an H1 straight to an H4, or using headings purely to make text bold, makes your page’s outline harder to follow. It’s not urgent, but tidy it up next time you edit the page. Think of it like the contents page of a book: chapters, then sections, then subsections.

Vague, duplicate or name-only title tags

A title tag of “Home” or “Kitchens | Smith & Co” tells searchers very little. Compare it with “Fitted kitchens in Newport, Isle of Wight | Smith & Co”. The second says what, where and who, which is exactly what someone scanning Google wants to know.

Duplicates are the other trap: if five pages share the same title, Google has no easy way to tell them apart, and it’s more likely to write its own.

On length, Google doesn’t set a character limit; it just cuts titles off to fit the screen. Around 50 to 60 characters keeps yours whole on most devices. As long as it isn’t a single word or a verbatim copy of Moby Dick, you’ll be fine.

Keyword stuffing

“SEO Isle of Wight | Isle of Wight SEO | Best SEO IOW” reads like spam, because it is. Google may rewrite a title like that, and people are far less likely to click it.

Use your main phrase once, naturally. Getting more specific does far more work than repetition: long-tail keywords like “bathroom showroom near Ryde” have far less competition than “bathrooms”.

Headings and titles are only two parts of the picture. If you want to work through the rest of your on-page checks, meta descriptions, internal links and images are the next places to look.

Why is Google showing a different title for my page?

Google writes its own headline when it thinks yours doesn’t describe the page well. Its documentation lists the usual triggers: titles that are half-empty or just a site name, outdated dates, the same boilerplate repeated across pages, titles that don’t match the content, and pages with no clear main heading.

The fix is to give every page a specific, honest title tag and an H1 that agrees with it. Once you’ve made changes, Google has to recrawl the page before anything updates, which can take anywhere from a few days to a few weeks. You can speed things along by requesting indexing in Google Search Console.

Do headings help you show up in AI search?

They help. AI tools like ChatGPT and Google’s AI Overviews pull short passages from web pages to build their answers, and clear, descriptive headings make it easier to find the passage that answers a question. A heading that asks a question, followed by a direct answer, is easy for them to pick up and quote.

Headings are one small piece of showing up in AI search, though. Being a business the AI tools recognise and trust matters far more.

What to ask your web designer

If someone else built your site, you don’t need to fix this yourself. Copy these questions into an email:

  1. Does every page have one H1 that describes that page?
  2. Is the logo or any banner text set as a heading, and can it be changed to normal text?
  3. Are heading levels chosen by structure, with sizes set in the styling?
  4. Does every page have its own title tag in the SEO plugin?
  5. Can you send me a list of pages with missing or duplicate titles?

A good web designer will be glad you asked. If they aren’t, that tells you something too. And if you’re planning a rebuild anyway, getting this right from day one is part of our WordPress web design as standard.

Want us to check it for you?

If you’d rather not poke around in heading levels, the team at Suki Marketing – an SEO and web design agency on the Isle of Wight – will do it for you. Book a free 30-minute call and we’ll look at your headings and title tags with you, tell you honestly what matters and what doesn’t, and leave you with a list you or your web designer can work through. No jargon, no hard sell.

If you’d rather hand the whole lot over, our on-page SEO service covers this and everything else on your pages. You’ll deal directly with the people doing the work, and you can get back to running your business.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many H1 tags should a page have?

One. Google has said its systems can handle more than one, but a single H1 that names the page’s topic is clearest for visitors, screen reader users and Google when it picks your headline. If your theme adds the logo or a slogan as an H1, change those to normal text.

Should my H1 and title tag be the same?

They don’t need to match, but they should agree. Your title tag is written to win the click in search results, so it often includes your location or brand. Your H1 greets people once they’re on the page. If the two describe different things, Google is more likely to rewrite your title.

How long should a title tag be?

Google has no character limit, but it trims titles to fit the screen. Around 50 to 60 characters usually shows in full. Put the most important words first, so that if the end does get cut off, searchers still see what the page is about and where you are.

My SEO plugin says my page has no H1. Is that serious?

It’s worth fixing, but don’t panic. Pages can still rank without an H1. The bigger issue is usually why it’s missing: often the page’s main heading has been set as an H2 for styling. Change that heading to an H1 in your page editor and the warning will clear.

Can I fix headings myself in WordPress or Elementor?

Usually, yes. In Elementor, click the heading, change the HTML tag in its content settings, then adjust the size in the Style tab. In the WordPress block editor, select the heading block and pick a level from the toolbar. Headings built into your theme or header may need your web designer.

Will fixing my headings improve my rankings straight away?

Probably not on its own. Headings help Google understand your page rather than push it up the results. What you may notice is better headlines in search and pages that are easier for visitors to read. Google also needs to recrawl the page first, which can take days to weeks.

Do headings matter on my homepage as much as on blog posts?

Yes, arguably more. Your homepage is where themes most often add extra H1s through the logo, sliders and banners. It’s also the page most people land on, so a clear H1 saying what you do and where you do it helps visitors and Google straight away.

in this article

Suzie Kidger, founder of Suki Marketing

Written by

Suzie Kidger

Suzie is the founder of Suki Marketing and has a real passion for all things search engine optimisation. With a wealth of knowledge across the whole SEO landscape, she has a particular love for digging around in websites to make those tricky technical fixes – to Suzie, there's nothing more satisfying. Suzie also has extensive experience making local businesses shine in search results. Having written engaging SEO content for a wide range of industries, including construction, hospitality, healthcare, fitness, and many others, she's skilled at making sure your expertise reaches the right audience.

Keep reading

More from the blog

See all articles →

More from the blog

Ready to get found?

Let's make it happen.

Book a free call