Most SEO sales calls sound the same, so the questions to ask an SEO agency need to cut through the polish. Ask what results they’ve had for businesses like yours, what they’ll do in the first 90 days, who does the work, how they measure success and how you leave. The answers are where the good ones stand out.
We’re an SEO agency, so yes, we know how a guide on how to choose an SEO agency looks coming from us. That’s why it also covers when you don’t need an agency at all, and how we’d answer every question ourselves. Feel free to put us to the same test.
The 10 questions to ask an SEO agency
If you only have a 30-minute call, ask these ten. You’re listening for specific, plain-English answers. Vague promises and confident jargon are exactly what you’re trying to filter out.
- Can you show me results for a business like mine?
- What’s realistic for my website, and by when?
- What would you do in the first 90 days, and what would you leave alone?
- What exactly will you do each month?
- How do you earn links?
- Who will actually do the work?
- How will you measure success?
- How are you handling AI search, such as ChatGPT and Google’s AI Overviews?
- How long is the contract, and how do I leave?
- Who owns my Search Console, Analytics and content?
Then ask one more: what would make you tell us SEO isn’t the right move for us right now? A good agency will have an honest answer. One that can’t think of a single reason is probably selling, not advising.
Before you ask anything: is an SEO agency right for you yet?
Not always. Hiring an SEO agency makes sense when you have a website worth building on, realistic expectations about timescales and nobody in-house with the time or skills. If your domain is brand new, you already pay a developer or you need results within weeks, an ongoing SEO retainer may not be the best use of your budget.
There are agencies out there who will take your money regardless. We’d rather tell you upfront when ongoing SEO isn’t the right fit, because a client whose expectations don’t match what SEO can actually do never stays happy for long.
If your domain is brand new
A website that launched last month and one that has been earning links and traffic for five years are starting from very different places. A new domain has no history with Google, few or no other websites linking to it and no data yet to show what’s working.
That doesn’t make SEO pointless. It means the strategy looks different: foundations first (a clean site structure, the right pages for the right searches and a Google Business Profile if you serve a local area), then content and authority built up over time. For a brand-new site in a competitive market, we talk in terms of a year rather than a quarter.
Any agency promising that a new website will beat established competitors within a few weeks is telling you what you want to hear.
If you already pay a developer
If you have a web developer or agency on a retainer, a chunk of the technical SEO work may already be within reach. Fixing broken links, tidying up headings and speeding up slow pages are often jobs a developer can do as part of what you already pay them for.
Here’s a real example. A property manager who runs their business solo came to us wanting to handle some of their marketing themselves, and they already paid an external web development agency. Rather than sell them ongoing SEO, we carried out an SEO audit and passed on a prioritised list of on-page and technical fixes for their developers to complete. These included multiple H1 headings on the same page, slow page speed and broken links.
Where an agency like ours adds value in that set-up is the work a developer doesn’t usually do: researching what your customers search for, writing the SEO content that answers them, and getting featured in AI answers. It also helps if your developer is comfortable with the technical SEO basics, such as making sure Google can crawl your pages, mobile-friendliness and Core Web Vitals (Google’s measures of page speed and stability).
If you need results in weeks, not months
SEO is slow by nature. Google needs time to crawl your changes, and rankings build over months rather than days. If you need enquiries next month, paid ads are usually the faster route, with SEO running alongside for the long term. An honest agency will say so.
If you’re happy to learn the basics yourself
You can do a lot of SEO yourself, especially local SEO. Google’s own guide to hiring an SEO points out that small local businesses can often do much of the work themselves. If you’ve got the time, start by doing your own SEO and bring in help when you reach the harder parts.
Questions about results and proof
Ask for results from businesses similar to yours, with a starting point, a timeframe and an outcome you care about, such as enquiries or sales. Then ask what’s realistic for your website specifically. A good SEO agency answers with evidence and caveats, not a guarantee.
Can you show me results for a business like mine?
Why ask: past results are the best predictor you’ve got, as long as they’re relevant to you.
What a good answer sounds like: a case study from a similar business that shows where they started, what the agency did, how long it took and what changed for the business. Even better if they’ll put you in touch with the client. Google’s hiring guidance suggests asking past clients whether the SEO was useful and easy to work with.
Red flag answer: a big percentage with no context. “We grew traffic by 300%” means nothing without the starting point, the timeframe and whether any of that traffic became customers.
You can browse our case studies and ask us about any of them.
What’s realistic for my site, and by when?
Why ask: the answer tells you whether they’ve actually looked at your website.
What a good answer sounds like: “It depends”, followed by what it depends on for your site: your starting point, your competitors and how much work is needed. Expect phases, with foundations and quick fixes first, then steadier growth over the following months.
Red flag answer: guaranteed rankings, or “page one in 30 days”. Google’s own guidance says nobody can guarantee a top ranking, so anyone promising one is either guessing or bending the rules.
Questions about the plan
Ask what they’d do in the first 90 days, what they’d deliberately leave alone, what you’ll get each month and how they’ll earn links. The best answers are specific to your website and explained in plain English. A generic package sent before anyone has looked at your site is a warning sign.
What would you do in the first 90 days, and what would you leave alone?
Why ask: it shows whether they prioritise or just pad.
What a good answer sounds like: a plan based on an audit of your site, your competitors and what your customers search for, in a clear order of priority. The “leave alone” part matters too. Knowing what isn’t worth your money yet is a sign of an agency that’s thinking about your budget, not theirs.
Red flag answer: a fixed number of blog posts and backlinks a month, decided before they understand your business.
What exactly will you do each month?
Why ask: you need to know what you’re paying for.
What a good answer sounds like: a list of work you could tick off, such as pages improved, content written, technical fixes made and a report. They should also say who does what: them, you or your developer.
Red flag answer: “We’ll optimise your website.” That’s a promise, not a deliverable.
How do you earn links?
Why ask: links from other websites still matter, but how you get them matters more.
What a good answer sounds like: relevant links earned through digital PR, genuinely useful content and local partnerships, with every link shared with you.
Red flag answer: hundreds of links a month, or links bought from networks of websites. Google’s spam policies treat buying links to manipulate rankings as a violation, and cleaning up after a penalty is slow, painful work.
Questions about the people
Ask who will actually do the work on your account, by name, and whether any of it is outsourced. The person who sells you SEO isn’t always the person who does it. A good agency tells you exactly who writes your content, fixes your site and reports to you.
Who will actually do the work?
What a good answer sounds like: named people, what each of them does and roughly how much time your account gets.
Red flag answer: a senior person on the sales call who you never hear from again, or an account manager who has to “check with the team” every time you ask a question.
Is any of it outsourced?
Outsourcing isn’t automatically bad, and plenty of agencies use trusted specialist freelancers.
What a good answer sounds like: an honest account of what’s outsourced, to whom, and who checks the quality before it reaches your website.
Red flag answer: dodging the question, or content churned out in bulk with nobody checking it. Google’s spam policies class mass-produced, low-value pages as scaled content abuse.
Questions about reporting
Ask how they’ll measure success and what their monthly report will show. Good agencies tie SEO to enquiries, sales or bookings, not just rankings and traffic. They also explain what changed, why it changed and what they’ll do next, in language you actually understand.
How will you measure success?
What a good answer sounds like: they ask what success means for your business, record where you’re starting from and agree a handful of measures with you. Those are usually enquiries or sales from organic search, traffic from people who didn’t already know your name, and visibility for the searches that matter. Rankings are useful for spotting problems, but they aren’t the goal.
Red flag answer: a dashboard full of numbers with no explanation, or “you now rank for 2,000 keywords!” when none of them bring in customers.
What would you look at if traffic goes up but enquiries don’t?
This is a brilliant question for testing whether an agency thinks commercially.
What a good answer sounds like: they’d check whether the new traffic matches what you sell, look at the pages people land on and test whether your forms or booking process are putting people off.
Red flag answer: “More traffic is always good.” It isn’t if it’s the wrong people.
Questions about AI search
Ask how they’re helping your business appear in AI answers from ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google’s AI Overviews, and how they measure it. A good agency builds on solid SEO, tests the questions your customers actually ask AI tools and never guarantees you’ll be cited.
How are you handling ChatGPT, Gemini and AI Overviews?
You’ll hear two terms here, and they’re related but not the same.
- AI SEO is about getting your own website ready to be cited and recommended in AI answers. That means content that answers questions clearly, structured data (code that explains your pages to search engines and AI tools) and making sure AI crawlers can read your site.
- GEO, or generative engine optimisation, is about your brand’s reputation across the wider web. That means consistent business details, mentions on other trusted websites and digital PR, so AI tools trust you enough to name you.
Both build on traditional SEO rather than replacing it. AI search is moving fast, so this reflects how things stand in October 2026.
What a good answer sounds like: they test the prompts your customers would use, track whether you’re mentioned or cited, and report AI visibility alongside rankings and enquiries, including how often you appear in Google’s AI Overviews.
Red flag answer: guaranteed AI citations, or “SEO is dead, you only need AI now”.
If AI tools keep naming other businesses instead of yours, it’s worth understanding why ChatGPT recommends your competitors.
Questions about contracts and your accounts
Ask how long the contract is, what the notice period is and who owns your accounts if you leave. A 3 to 6 month initial commitment is common because SEO takes time to work. What matters more is a clear way out, no automatic renewal traps and your data staying yours.
How long is the contract, and how do I leave?
SEO contract length is a common worry, and fair enough. Because SEO takes months to show results, it’s reasonable for an agency to suggest committing for a few months.
What a good answer sounds like: a clear reason for the length, a point where you review progress together and a notice period written into the contract.
Red flag answer: 12 months with no break clause, automatic renewal with a long notice window or a fee for leaving.
Who owns my Search Console, Analytics and content?
You do. Always.
Google Search Console is Google’s free tool that shows how your website performs in search. Google Analytics 4 (GA4) shows what visitors do once they arrive. Both should be set up under a Google account your business controls, with the agency added as a user.
- In Search Console, Full user access lets an agency do the work without making them an owner. Google recommends giving read-only access during an audit.
- In GA4, Editor access lets an agency set up tracking, and Analyst access is enough if they only need to read reports. You keep the Administrator role, which is the only one that can manage users (Analytics Help).
- When you part ways, remove their access. If they were ever a verified owner, delete their verification token too, or they can re-verify themselves. Google’s Search Console help explains how.
If you don’t have them yet, a good agency will set them up in your name. The same goes for tools like Microsoft Clarity, a free tool that shows heatmaps and recordings of real visits, so you can see where people click, scroll and give up.
Red flag answer: an agency that insists on owning your accounts, your domain or your website.
Questions a good SEO agency should ask you
It should be a two-way conversation. A good agency asks about your customers, your most profitable services, your competitors and how people find you now. Google’s guidance says a good SEO should be interested in your business. If an agency starts pitching before asking you anything, be wary.
Expect questions like these:
- Who are your best customers, and how do they usually find you?
- Which services or products make you the most money?
- Who do you lose work to?
- How do enquiries come in now, and what happens to them?
- What is your website built on, and who looks after it?
- Have you worked with an SEO agency before, and what didn’t work?
- What would success look like for you in six months?
SEO agency red flags to listen for
The biggest red flags are guaranteed rankings, vague monthly deliverables, bulk link building, long contracts with no way out and an agency that wants to own your accounts. Unsolicited emails promising page one belong in the bin too.
Google’s own hiring guidance adds a few more to watch for:
- A claimed “special relationship” with Google, or a “priority submit” service
- Secrecy, or vague explanations of what they’ll do
- Requests to link back to the agency from your website
- Submitting your site to thousands of search engines
If a price looks too low to cover the work being promised, it probably is. We’ve explained the problem with cheap SEO and what genuine SEO costs in the UK.
How we’d answer these questions
Fair’s fair. Here’s how Suki Marketing would answer the questions above. We’re a small SEO and web design agency based on the Isle of Wight, working with businesses across the UK, and you deal directly with the people doing the work. Our 5.0 Google rating helps, but the answers below matter more.
| Your question | Our answer |
|---|---|
| Results for a business like mine? | Our case studies cover tourism, ecommerce, recruitment and more. We’ll talk you through the one closest to your business. |
| What’s realistic, and by when? | It depends on where your site starts. We’ll tell you honestly, including when it’s a year rather than a quarter. |
| The first 90 days? | An audit first, then a plan of priorities agreed with you. |
| What happens each month? | A clear list of work, in plain English. |
| Who does the work? | Suzie and our small team. There are no account managers in between, and our SEO content is written through AI and human power, with solid research behind it. |
| How do you measure success? | A jargon-free monthly report covering rankings, traffic, enquiries and AI visibility. |
| AI search? | AI SEO and GEO are part of how we work, built on solid SEO foundations. |
| Contract length? | No lock-ins. We recommend committing 3 to 6 months to see results, but we won’t tie you in. |
| Your accounts? | Always yours. You share access with us, and we can set up Search Console, GA4 and Microsoft Clarity if you don’t have them. |
| Price? | Our fully managed SEO starts from £950 per month (no VAT added). |
When we’re not the right fit: you’ve just launched a brand-new domain and need results in weeks, or you’d rather learn to do the basics yourself. Or, like the property manager above, you already pay a developer who can make the technical fixes. In that last case, an audit and a clear handover may be all you need. We’ll tell you if that’s the case.
Bring your questions to us
Book a free 30-minute call and ask us every question on this list. If we’re not the right fit, we’ll say so, and point you somewhere better. If you’d rather put it in writing, get in touch and we’ll get back to you.